[dba-VB] Recent Discussion from MS on VB.Net and C# in VS 2010

Drew Wutka DWUTKA at Marlow.com
Tue Mar 16 12:43:56 CDT 2010


Actually, I'm enjoying the discussion, don't leave yet.  I installed
Visual Studio 2008 months ago, cause some day I'm going to dig into C#
and VB.Net when I have time! (that very well might be after the world is
destroyed in 2012, but hey, here's hoping I get to it!)

LOL.

I would like to point out that your example (X + Y) * (Z^2-3) isn't
using parenthesis for 'readability'.  You have addition in the first,
and subtraction in the last, and multiplication in between, if you
didn't have parenthesis in your statement, the function would be
completely different.  Please Excuse My Dear Aunt Sally.

But you bring up a good point, about mathematics and coding.  Usually
coders are good at math.  Now don't take this the wrong way, cause this
specifically isn't pointed at you, but in my experience, a lot of
'developers' are actually database people that have picked up coding,
and coders are usually only using a database to store data relevant to
their code.  It's rare to find people that delve into multiple worlds
and have them come out with compartmentalized understanding, or even
relational understanding between the various worlds.  But it's almost
impossible to have people learn another sphere of learning without
picking up some 'quirks' from the learning source! ;)  

So as to your statement about brackets 'simplifying'
grouping/readability, I think that needs to be substantiated a little
more.  In the C world, which has it's own structure, it makes sense.  In
the examples:

class SomeClass
{ 
    private int someField; 
 
    public int SomeField 
    { 
        get { return SomeField; }  
    }
}

Can be written as...
class SomeClass
{ 
    public int SomeField { Get; }
}

3 groups in one, 2 in another.  In VB:

Public SomeField as Integer

No grouping at all, but it's only one property, in what could be a
simple class. In your example, (X + Y) * (Z^2-3), what good does (X + Y)
* ((Z^2)-3) do?  It doesn't change anything, and it really doesn't make
anything more or less readable.  In fact, it is just lengthening the
function.  

Moreover, both languages are commonly indented in groupings.  

If Something Then
	Do Something
Else
	Do SomethingElse
End if

Brackets in the indentations are just overkill.

Now, seriously, I can't believe you find {} and case sensitivity to be
actual attractions to C#.  I can understand that it may make sense
within the C# paradigm, couldn't argue that if I wanted too!  What is
the pull to C#, other than more googable source and client requests.  Is
there any aspects of the language where you can truly do something that
others can't?  (From my personal perspective, there is functionally
nothing I can't do in VB, that you can do in anything else.  I don't
program for OSes other then Windows, and many of the 'limitations' of VB
6, such as multi-threaded or NT services, I can actually do.  I would
like true inheritance, so that is my only real pull into the .Net world
at all, right now!) 

Drew


-----Original Message-----
From: dba-vb-bounces at databaseadvisors.com
[mailto:dba-vb-bounces at databaseadvisors.com] On Behalf Of jwcolby
Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 7:21 AM
To: Discussion concerning Visual Basic and related programming issues.
Subject: Re: [dba-VB] Recent Discussion from MS on VB.Net and C# in VS
2010

LOL.  It is amazing to me that everyone on this list never thinks a
thing about using parenthesis to 
group mathematics for readability and to specify execution order and yet
we have people bitching and 
moaning about a programming language that does the EXACT same thing!

;)

(X + Y) * (z^2-3)

Who in their right minds would WANT

begin  X+1 end * begin x^2 -3 end

Which is the more readable?

In the end it is all about comfort level.  People (me included) don't
want to have to take the time 
and effort to learn a new way.

I am making the effort and I am happy I am, and it is a waste of time
and breath to continue this 
conversation further.  Do I really care whether Max (or anyone else)
wants to do the same?

John W. Colby
www.ColbyConsulting.com


The information contained in this transmission is intended only for the person or entity 
to which it is addressed and may contain II-VI Proprietary and/or II-VI Business 
Sensitive material. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender 
immediately and destroy the material in its entirety, whether electronic or hard copy. 
You are notified that any review, retransmission, copying, disclosure, dissemination, 
or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon this information by persons 
or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited.





More information about the dba-VB mailing list