Arthur Fuller
fuller.artful at gmail.com
Fri May 27 11:09:02 CDT 2011
With all due respect, I suggest that you read some Codd and Date on this topic.As for the complexities involved in use of IKs, it is brain-dead easy. But that said, I am not a big fan of IKs. Like most of us on this forum, I tend to favour AutoNumber out of force of habit rather than rational analysis. I have read numerous things by Joe Celko and Chis Date which refute the use of AutoNumber|Idnentity Keys, and I accept them halfway. I don't give a fork from which a given tire was hatched, unless and until several of these instances have caused highway fatalities. Therefore, I need build this (batch) into the design, so that I can report to all owners of said tires a warning that there are potential issues. This is going to be extremely problematic to solve with the AutoNumber scenario. An intelligent key could make the query dramatically simpler. That's all I'm saying. I typically use AutoNumbers in almost every app I write, but the more crucial and life-threatening the app, the more likely I shall use IKs. A.