Francisco Tapia
fhtapia at gmail.com
Thu Mar 16 17:59:31 CST 2006
John, You make an interesting case, I've used spysweeper and pest pastrol on my system and found them that they were trying to clober my "wise instalbuilder" product. I use this product on a regular bais to deploy my in house application. I thought it odd that spysweeper and pest patrol would find items in the wise folder and would try to delete them... (things such as unwise.exe) I used counterspy on a machine that was heavily plauged w/ spyware and would be scheduled for an fdisk,... counterspy did not locate the vumundo spyware that was on there.. for that matter neither did any of the 3 freebies that I mentioned.. I had to search google to find the fix. So I can't refer people to pay for a product that won't help them, instead i've directed users to products such as firefox w/ adblock and noscript. this ensures that code can't run on sites that are questionable. and while I agree that sygate is dead as a product, i have yet to find a suitable replacement for it. I've used keiro but not in the recent months that sunbelt has acuired it. i may take another look, but i can't recomend it at this time... I found that while surfing you can't completely stealth your system w/ it. and the last time I used it you could only granularly allow programs through on the paid version. On 3/15/06, John Bartow <john at winhaven.net> wrote: > Francisco, > If they weren't better than the 3 freebies I wouldn't make an issue of it, > but you are clearly mistaken. And I'm not a brand name adherent (as anyone > that reads my posts would know). Do your own evaluation of all of them at > the same time and you'll never make such a statement again. MS anti-spyware > is a joke these days (I still use it PCs where they won't PAY for a real > time anti-spyware program). It holds up well to the statement "its better > than nothing". > > I also use Spybot S&D and Adaware (and a number of other products) on a > regular basis and they just don't compare. Often times they will claim to > have removed the malware but haven't or in the case of Spybot will want to > do a scan at startup which rarely accomplishes anything. Don't get me wrong, > I love those products. They will install and run in safe mode CS won't > <grr>. And they are better than MS's. But they don't hold up against > CounterSpy, Pest Patrol or SpySweeper. These three are consistently top > rated while others bounce up and down depending who's doing the rating. > CounterSpy actually uses the MS-AS malware database as ONE of its THREE data > sources (because they had a contract before MS bought Giant) so how you can > claim that MS-AS is better I just don't know! I hope MS does come through > with a decent AS product but I'm not waiting for the day. > > If you know about anti-spyware, you also know that at this point in time no > one product will detect and remove all spyware. > > As far as firewalls go, I agree, Sygate PF is great. I probably learned > about it from this list years ago. But its dead. Therefore I replaced it > with Kerio, which I probably learned about from this list too. So while > Kerio will only get better, Sygate will only get antiquated. And the real > big catch is: how do I refer people to a dead product? > > -----Original Message----- > From: dba-tech-bounces at databaseadvisors.com > [mailto:dba-tech-bounces at databaseadvisors.com] On Behalf Of Francisco Tapia > Sent: Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:52 PM > To: Discussion of Hardware and Software issues > Subject: Re: [dba-Tech] Norton Antivirus Activation > > i dunno , i've used these products before and my general thoughts were that > they don't hold their own against quality products such as spybot or adaware > or even MS's antispyware. for firewalls, i still quite prefer sygate. I > haven't ran into something that is better for the monies. tho now that > symantec bought them only to kill the product. > > -- -Francisco http://pcthis.blogspot.com |PC news with out the jargon! http://sqlthis.blogspot.com | Tsql and More...